Game Preview · NFL
Commanders vs. Giants Prediction and Pick: Deane's Best Bet for Thursday
By Wyatt Deane — Spent nine seasons breaking down All-22 film for a college staff. Wyatt covers the NFL and college football through matchups and personnel.
One game on the Thursday slate, and it is a division meeting at MetLife Stadium with the Commanders visiting the Giants at 8:15 p.m. ET. Washington comes in at 2-5-1 and winless on the road at 0-3, carrying a -30 point differential through eight games. The Giants are laying 2 points at home, and this one comes down to whether the Commanders can stay on the field on third down against a defense that has been getting off it.
The Pick
Pick: New York Giants -2 (-110 at BetMGM)
Washington is converting 30.1% of its third downs, dead last in the NFL at 32nd. That is the whole game right there. An offense that cannot extend drives on the road, in possible rain with wind around 12 mph, is going to spend the night punting and handing the Giants short fields.
The passing numbers make it worse. The Commanders gain 6.1 yards per pass attempt, and the Giants are giving up just 5.5 per attempt, third in the league. So even when Washington tries to throw its way back into manageable downs, it is throwing into one of the better pass defenses in football by that measure. The Giants defense is allowing 21.5 points per game, 12th in the NFL, while Washington is scoring 21.5 per game through 8 games, 21st. One of those units is holding up its end and the other is not.
On the other side of the ball, the Commanders defense is allowing 25.3 points per game, 24th in the league. That means the Giants do not need a big night from their offense to cover a short number. They need to be average, and average has been enough against Washington all year. The Commanders are 0-3 on the road for a reason.
What worries me is J.J. McCarthy being listed as questionable, because a backup plan at quarterback changes how comfortable I feel laying points with anybody. Washington is also +7 in turnover margin through 8 games, so if the Giants give the ball away, this gets tight fast. But the down-to-down matchup is lopsided, and I trust the team that gets off the field against the team that never stays on it.
The Play
- New York Giants -2: -110